Skip to Content

Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream

This post may include affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Sharing is caring!

This old fashioned banana pudding ice cream is creamy and dreamy and tastes like your favorite southern dessert – banana pudding! Made with fresh bananas, banana pudding, and crispy vanilla wafers. You’ll love this summertime treat!

This old fashioned banana pudding ice cream is creamy and dreamy and tastes like your favorite southern dessert - banana pudding! Made with fresh bananas, banana pudding, and crispy vanilla wafers. You'll love this summertime treat! 

Today’s recipe is brought to you by Kristen of Dine & Dish. Kristen cooks up delicious looking food and shares heartwarming stories about her family. She has four kids and still has time to make beautiful (and delicious!) food and take amazing pictures. I’m not sure where she gets her energy but I will gladly take some!

Homemade ice cream… there’s nothing quite like it, is there? I remember as a child, the promise of licking the beater if I agreed to be the one who sat on the wooden ice cream maker while my dad or mom cranked the handle.

It was an arborous process, but the reward was well worth it. Getting to be the first to taste whatever flavor of ice cream was being created was a prize worth sitting in the sun and being bored for a while for.

When Brandy asked me to participate in her Ice Cream Social, I immediately knew what kind of ice cream I wanted to create. While on vacation in Estes Park, CO recently, we were treated to the most incredible old fashioned banana pudding ice cream. I’d never tasted anything like it before. Cold and creamy ice cream with chunks of fresh bananas and bits of the vanilla wafer.

It’s a favorite old-fashioned dessert in frozen form and boy is it good!

This old fashioned banana pudding ice cream is creamy and dreamy and tastes like your favorite southern dessert - banana pudding! Made with fresh bananas, banana pudding, and crispy vanilla wafers. You'll love this summertime treat! 

My secret ingredient in milkshakes has always been a tablespoon or two of instant pudding mix. Seriously, it sounds weird, but the instant pudding mix adds a depth of flavor you just can’t get without it.

I decided to see if I could do the same thing with the old fashioned banana pudding ice cream recipe I created and sure enough… the banana flavor ended up being so full and vibrant. My kids nominated this as the “best ice cream they’ve ever tasted”.

I hope you enjoy it!

Looking for even more ice cream recipes? Try my Raspberry Chocolate Chip Ice CreamApple Butter Gingersnap Ice CreamNo Churn Cherry Amaretto Ice CreamPeanut Butter Oreo Ice Cream or my Carrot Cake Ice Cream

Print

Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream

This old fashioned banana pudding ice cream is creamy and dreamy and tastes like your favorite southern dessert - banana pudding! Made with fresh bananas, banana pudding, and crispy vanilla wafers. You'll love this summertime treat! 

Yield: 1 quart

Prep Time: 30 minutes

Cook Time: 0 minutes

Total Time: 30 minutes

Ingredients:

  • 1 -1/2 cups heavy whipping cream
  • 1 -1/2 cups whole milk
  • 3 egg yolks
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1/4 teaspoon Kosher salt
  • 1 teaspoon lemon juice
  • 3 Tablespoons instant banana pudding mix
  • 2 small bananas, sliced
  • 1 cup vanilla wafers, coarsely chopped

Source: Kristen Doyle of Dine & Dish

Directions:

In the bowl of an electric mixer, mix the whipping cream, milk, and eggs.

Slowly add the sugar, lemon juice and Kosher salt. Finally, add the instant banana pudding mix and blend well.

Using a wooden spoon, add the small banana slices and stir to incorporate.

Pour into the freezer bowl of your electric ice cream maker. Turn on and freeze according to the manufactures directions.

During the final 10 minutes of freezing, add the coarsely chopped vanilla wafers.

Remove frozen ice cream. Serve immediately or place in a freezer proof ice cream container and serve when ready.

Previous
Vanilla Malted Brownie Ice Cream
Next
Pound Cake Parfait Sundae

Katrina

Monday 5th of August 2019

I really want to try this recipe, I love how you don't have to cook and cool the mix before freezing. Is it safe to use egg yolks that haven't been cooked or tempered though?

nutmegnanny

Friday 6th of September 2019

Hi Kartina - if you're worried about eating uncooked eggs you can often find pasteurized eggs in the store. I eat uncooked eggs often (cookie dough, egg nog, etc.) but you should only eat what you're comfortable eating.

tell me all about your day! – – homemade banana pudding ice cream -

Tuesday 30th of July 2013

[...] made some old fashioned banana pudding homemade ice cream on the 4th of july. somehow we found the time while also watching grey crawl for the first [...]

Alicia

Monday 8th of July 2013

I made this ice cream for a 4th of July BBQ, and everyone raved about it!! It was a huge hit. Thanks for sharing.

Tia

Thursday 23rd of May 2013

This recipe looks delicious! I am making this for our Memorial Day cookout! How much ice cream does this make? I'm using an ice cream maker for this recipe! Thank you!

nutmegnanny

Friday 24th of May 2013

Hi Tia! It should make around 1 quart. Hope you enjoy the ice cream!

Nutmeg Nanny » Ice Cream Social Round-Up & Le Creuset Giveaway

Wednesday 29th of August 2012

[...] two: Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream from Dine & Dish. This is the stuff that southern dreams are made [...]

shares